| 1872 Mrs. John Stewart | 1973-1974 Mrs. Thomas Walsh |
| 1873-1883 Miss Julia Johns | 1975-1976 Mrs. Wesley Chappel |
| 1884-1885 Miss Eliza H. Miller | 1977-1978 Mrs. Donald Wells |
| 1886-1893 Miss Eliza W. Smith | 1979-1980 Mrs. Samuel A. Dickens |
| 1894-1913 Mrs. William G. Boothe | 1981-1982 Mrs. John R. Smucker |
| 1914-1917 Mrs. R.M. Ballenger | 1983-1984 Mrs. William C. Forbes |
| 1918-1923 Mrs. L. Wilbur Reed | 1985-1986 Mrs. Benjamin H. Burrell |
| 1924-1928 Miss Rebecca Klipstein | 1987-1988 Mrs. John W. Sullivan |
| 1929-1938 Mrs. S. Cooper Dawson | 1989-1990 Mrs. Melvin Kilian |
| 1939-1940 Mrs. Ann B. Wicks | 1991-1994 Betty Lankford McLaughlin |
| 1941-1943 Mrs. James Werth | 1995-1996 Mrs. Samuel A. Dickens |
| 1944-1946 Mrs. Sylvern S. Laupheimer | 1997-1998 Mrs. Paul M. Harris |
| 1947-1948 Mrs. James E. Dowie | 1999-2002 Mrs. Ray Lewis |
| 1949-1950 Mrs. Joseph E. Harris | 2003-2004 Barbara Brenman |
| 1951-1952 Mrs. Ernst Wiecking | 2005-2006 Mrs. Diane G. Argerson |
| 1953-1954 Mrs. Harold M. Schultz | 2007-2008 Mrs. Penelope M. Alatis |
| 1955-1956 Mrs. Edwin A. Johnson | 2009-2010 Mrs. Judy F. Doering |
| 1957-1960 Mrs. Fred W. Erhard | 2011-2012 Ms. Cynthia Puskar |
| 1961-1962 Mrs. Isaac Gregory | 2013-2014 Mrs. Ruth A. Corlett |
| 1963-1965 Mrs. Kenneth H. Moore | 2015-2016 Mrs. Connie Blood |
| 1966-1968 Mrs. Lester MacFarland | 2017-2018 Donita Greene |
| 1969-1970 Mrs. Clyde Warren | 2019-2020 Charlotte Tsoucalas |
| 1971-1972 Mrs. James Malley | 2021-2022 Mary Ryan |
